Noven True is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Mortgage Rates Are Close — Your Borrower Profile Matters More
The listed rates range from 4.19% to 4.79%, but property type, deposit size and lender criteria can change the real cost.
Mortgage rates in this comparison sit within a narrow band: 4.19% to 4.79%. That 0.60 percentage-point gap matters, but it is not the first thing to compare. The bigger question is whether the lender accepts your property, income pattern, deposit and borrowing purpose.
There is also a sharp divide in this list. HSBC, Nationwide, NatWest, Yorkshire Building Society and Barclays target mainstream residential borrowers, while Shawbrook, Fleet, Paragon, Together Money and Precise Mortgages focus on landlords or specialist cases.
Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.
What to compare before you apply
Start with the mortgage purpose. A residential mortgage for your own home is not interchangeable with a buy-to-let loan. Shawbrook, for example, advertises landlord borrowing from £50,000 to £50 million, with interest-only options up to 75% loan-to-value subject to affordability. That tells you immediately that it belongs in a different comparison from a first-home mortgage.
Next, check the total cost rather than the headline rate. Ask about product fees, valuation charges, legal costs, early repayment charges and the rate you move to after a fixed period. The supplied pages do not provide a full fee schedule for most mainstream lenders, so the displayed rates should be treated as comparison markers, not final quotes.
Finally, test the monthly payment at a higher rate. A mortgage that only works at the initial rate leaves little room for household bills, repairs or a future income change.
What most borrowers get wrong
- Comparing a buy-to-let rate with a residential rate as if they were the same product.
- Focusing on the initial rate while ignoring fees and the follow-on rate.
- Assuming a lender's online calculator is a formal approval.
- Borrowing to the maximum available amount without keeping an emergency reserve.
Mainstream residential mortgages
The residential group is where most owner-occupiers should begin. The listed rates are close, so service model, eligibility and the help available during a difficult period may matter more than a small headline difference.
HSBC Mortgage
HSBC is listed at 4.29% and provides an online rate comparison route rather than publishing a complete mortgage price list in the supplied page. The useful detail is its reference to Mortgage Charter support and additional options for customers dealing with cost-of-living pressure. Best for an owner-occupier who wants a large-bank application route and may value payment-support options. The downside is that the page gives too little fee and eligibility detail to justify choosing it on rate alone.
HSBC Mortgage
Nationwide Building Society Mortgage
Nationwide shows 4.24%, slightly below HSBC's listed 4.29%, and explicitly mentions first-time buyers as well as existing borrowers switching deals. That wider audience makes it easier to place in a residential shortlist. Best for a first-time buyer or homeowner nearing remortgage who wants a building society comparison route. The page still does not reveal the full fees or product-specific criteria, so the 0.05-point rate advantage should not decide the application by itself.
Nationwide Building Society Mortgage
Precise Mortgages Specialist Lending
Precise Mortgages is not a straightforward rate-led alternative: its page is built around intermediary access and lists residential, bridging and product-transfer routes. That makes it relevant when a standard high-street application does not fit, but less useful as a first stop for a simple purchase. Best for a borrower with a non-standard case who is working through a mortgage adviser. The supplied information does not include a representative rate, so affordability and fees need to be confirmed before comparing it with the 4.19% to 4.34% mainstream listings.
Precise Mortgages Specialist Lending
NatWest Mortgage
NatWest lists mortgages for applicants over 18 and includes the key warning that the property may be repossessed if repayments are missed. Its displayed rate is 4.34%, higher than Nationwide's 4.24% and Barclays' 4.19% in this set. Best for an adult owner-occupier who wants a mainstream bank application and understands the security attached to mortgage borrowing. The rate gap is modest, but a higher offer would need to be offset by fees, criteria or a better fit for your circumstances.
NatWest Mortgage
Yorkshire Building Society Mortgage
Yorkshire Building Society is listed at 4.29%, matching HSBC, and its page includes guidance on how Bank of England base-rate changes can affect mortgage and savings customers. That educational context is useful for borrowers comparing fixed and variable-rate risk, although it is not a promise of a cheaper deal. Best for a homeowner who wants a building society route and is prepared to examine how rate changes affect the household budget. The supplied page does not state product fees, so the matching headline rate does not make it automatically cheaper than Nationwide.
For official details, compare the lender pages directly: HSBC mortgages, Nationwide mortgages and NatWest mortgages. The headline figures here are not interchangeable offers; the product fee and eligibility check can reverse the ranking.
Nationwide is the cleanest starting point for a first-time buyer based on the listed 4.24% rate and explicit first-time-buyer positioning. Barclays has the lowest displayed rate, but its supplied page contains too little detail to assess the total cost. That gap is exactly why a rate table alone is not enough.
Buy-to-let and specialist lending
Landlords need a separate test: rent coverage, loan-to-value, property type, portfolio size and ownership structure can matter as much as personal income. The specialist lenders below are not substitutes for the residential picks above.
Shawbrook Bank BTL Mortgage
Shawbrook is the most clearly documented specialist lender in the list. It advertises buy-to-let borrowing from £50,000 to £50 million, interest-only options up to 75% loan-to-value subject to affordability, and support for portfolios, HMOs and more complex property needs. Best for a professional landlord buying or refinancing larger or less standard investments. The 4.79% listed rate is the highest figure in this comparison, so the scale and flexibility need to solve a real property problem before the extra cost makes sense.
Shawbrook Bank BTL Mortgage
Fleet Mortgages BTL Mortgage
Fleet Mortgages is aimed at intermediaries rather than casual direct applicants, and the supplied page announces new five-year fixed-rate products carrying a 5% fee. That fee is substantial: on a £200,000 mortgage it would equal £10,000 before other costs. Best for an experienced landlord comparing fixed-rate certainty and able to calculate the fee against the expected holding period. Skip any product comparison that looks only at the rate; the fee can dominate the total cost.
Fleet Mortgages BTL Mortgage
Paragon Bank BTL Mortgage
Paragon is labelled as a buy-to-let mortgage provider, but the supplied page contains little usable product detail beyond its personal-mortgage site navigation. That makes it a research lead, not a rate recommendation. Best for a landlord willing to request current criteria through the provider or an adviser rather than relying on a public headline. Compared with Shawbrook, it offers less visible information here, so transparency is the main weakness.
Yorkshire Building Society Mortgage
Yorkshire Building Society belongs in the residential group, not the landlord shortlist, and that distinction matters. Its supplied page discusses mortgage and savings customers and base-rate effects, but gives no buy-to-let terms. Best for an owner-occupier assessing rate risk, not a landlord searching for portfolio finance. Keeping it separate from Shawbrook and Fleet prevents a misleading comparison between different underwriting rules.
Together Money BTL Mortgage
Together Money advertises buy-to-let borrowing for first-time landlords through to portfolio owners, accepts individuals and limited companies, places no stated limit on the number of properties, and says there is no maximum age where the loan is self-funded. Best for a landlord using a limited company structure or building a portfolio beyond a single property. The page does not provide a representative rate or fee, so the flexibility must be weighed against a written quote rather than the promise of broad eligibility alone.
Together Money BTL Mortgage
Shawbrook and Together provide the clearest evidence of scale and portfolio flexibility, while Fleet's published 5% fee demands careful arithmetic. Precise Mortgages may belong in a specialist adviser conversation, but its supplied information is too limited for a direct price ranking. For landlord borrowing, rental stress tests and all-in fees deserve more attention than the lowest displayed rate.
Common mortgage mistakes and the fix
- Mistake: Treating a representative rate as a personal offer. Fix: Ask for the lender's eligibility assumptions and an agreement in principle.
- Mistake: Ignoring product fees. Fix: Add every fee to the interest cost and compare the total over the period you expect to keep the deal.
- Mistake: Using residential criteria for buy-to-let. Fix: Check rent coverage, property type, LTV and ownership structure separately.
- Mistake: Borrowing at the maximum. Fix: Run the payment at a higher rate and leave cash for repairs, moving costs and income shocks.
Quick decision framework
Buying your first home? Start with Nationwide at the listed 4.24%, then compare HSBC, Yorkshire Building Society, NatWest and Barclays on fees and eligibility. Nationwide is the most clearly positioned for first-time buyers in the supplied material.
Already own a home and switching deals? Compare Nationwide's switching route with HSBC, Yorkshire Building Society and NatWest. Do not assume staying with the current provider is cheapest; request the total cost for the new fixed or variable period.
Buying a rental property? Begin with Shawbrook if you need borrowing from £50,000 upwards, portfolio support or an HMO route. Compare Together if limited-company ownership, multiple properties or age flexibility matters. Examine Fleet only after calculating the impact of its stated 5% fee.
Have a complex case? Speak with an adviser about Precise Mortgages and request written fees, criteria and repayment terms. The specialist route may open doors, but the missing public rate information means you should not assume it is cheaper.
My practical shortlist is simple: Nationwide for a first-time buyer, HSBC or Yorkshire Building Society for mainstream comparison, Shawbrook for larger landlord borrowing, and Together for portfolio or limited-company flexibility. Barclays has the lowest displayed rate at 4.19%, but the supplied details are too thin to make it the automatic winner.
For a broader comparison across owner-occupier, landlord and homeowner scenarios, read Mortgage Picks for Buyers, Landlords and Homeowners.
