Noven True is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Car Finance Rates Span 4.9% to 69.9% APR
Eight car-finance listings show a wide cost gap, from 4.9% advertised APR to 69.9% for some poor-credit borrowers.
The average advertised starting APR across these eight car-finance listings is 7.9%, but the spread is huge: the highest listed rate reaches 69.9% for some poor-credit applicants. The average maximum finance amount is £67,857.14, compared with an average minimum of £2,857.14.
That gap matters more than the headline rate. A low starting APR may be available only to applicants with strong credit, while specialist bad-credit finance can cost several times more. Noven True compares lenders and brokers; it does not lend directly.
Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.
The cheapest advertised rates are dealer-led
As the chart shows, the lowest listed starting APR belongs to Black Horse at 4.9%. Close Brothers and MotoNovo follow at 5.9%. Those figures are attractive, but all three providers generally work through dealerships or intermediaries rather than taking direct consumer applications.
Black Horse's official car-finance page lists PCP and HP for new and used vehicles, while Close Brothers describes a broad dealer and broker network. The practical lesson is simple: ask the dealer for the representative APR, total amount payable, deposit, mileage limits and final balloon payment. Do not compare monthly payments alone.
CarFinance 247 and Zuto both advertise rates from 8.9%. They are brokers, not lenders, so the quoted rate depends on the lender ultimately selected and your credit profile. Zuto says decisions can arrive in 60 seconds without affecting your credit score, but its representative APR is much higher than the starting figure.
Black Horse Car Finance
Black Horse has the lowest advertised starting APR in this group at 4.9%, plus PCP and HP through dealerships. The rate is not guaranteed, and the dealer-only model gives you less control over the lender and any dealer margin. Ask for the total repayment figure before accepting the monthly quote.
Black Horse Car Finance
Close Brothers Motor Finance
Close Brothers sits just behind Black Horse at a 5.9% listed starting rate and covers new and used cars through intermediaries. That network is useful if you are already buying from a dealer, but direct applications are not available and the final rate can depend on the dealer relationship.
Close Brothers Motor Finance
MotoNovo Finance
MotoNovo also lists rates from 5.9% and supports both HP and PCP across a large dealership network. It may suit a used-car buyer who wants product choice, but the rate varies by credit profile and the application must go through a dealer.
MotoNovo Finance
CarFinance 247
CarFinance 247 is a broker with rates from 8.9% and a 19.5% representative APR according to its listing. The gap between those figures is the point: applicants should treat 8.9% as a best-case starting point, not a likely personal offer.
CarFinance 247
These lower starting rates are useful benchmarks, not promises. The FCA explains that representative APR must be available to a stated proportion of successful applicants, but individual offers can still differ sharply. Use the advertised figures to shortlist providers, then compare the personalised quote and total amount payable.
Bad credit is not an automatic barrier, but it is expensive
Moneybarn is the clearest outlier. Its representative APR is 30.7%, with rates reaching 69.9% for the poorest credit profiles. It considers poor or limited credit histories, but that access comes at a steep price.
According to Moneybarn's car-finance page, the provider finances cars priced from £3,000 to £25,000 and focuses on HP rather than PCP. That can help someone who needs ownership at the end of the agreement, but the higher APR can add thousands to the repayment cost. Improve your credit file, reduce the amount borrowed or choose a cheaper vehicle before accepting a high-rate agreement.
Oodle lists a 7.9% starting price and says applicants can receive a decision within minutes using a soft credit check. Its listing also warns that lower credit scores attract higher rates. Zuto's 8.9% starting rate comes with a representative APR of 18.8% in the listing, showing how far the personal quote can move from the headline.
Moneybarn Car Finance for Poor Credit
Moneybarn is the practical fallback for drivers with poor or limited credit, not the cheap route. Its 30.7% representative APR and possible rates up to 69.9% make affordability checks essential. HP means ownership at the end, but only if every repayment is made.
Moneybarn Car Finance for Poor Credit
Oodle Car Finance
Oodle combines used-car HP with a soft credit check and decisions in minutes, which can reduce wasted applications. The 7.9% starting rate looks better than Moneybarn's, but borrowers with weaker credit should expect a higher personal APR and should compare the full repayment schedule.
Oodle Car Finance
Zuto Car Finance
Zuto gives shoppers access to multiple lenders and says its initial decision takes 60 seconds without affecting the credit score. The representative APR of 18.8% is the more useful figure than the 8.9% starting rate, so use the broker to compare rather than assuming the lowest headline price.
Zuto Car Finance
There is no aggregate evidence here proving that larger loans are cheaper per pound. The listings provide average minimum and maximum amounts, but not matched APRs, fees or repayment terms by loan size. That means a larger vehicle loan may have a lower rate for a strong borrower, yet still cost more in total because the balance is bigger.
Fast approval also needs careful wording. Oodle states that decisions can arrive in minutes, and Zuto advertises a 60-second decision, but neither figure guarantees funding or acceptance. Treat speed as an application feature, not proof of affordability.
What to do before choosing a car-finance deal
Start with the total amount payable. A 4.9% headline rate can still be poor value if the car price, deposit, fees or final balloon payment are inflated.
- Ask whether the quote is HP or PCP and check who owns the vehicle during the agreement.
- Compare the representative APR with your personalised APR before signing.
- Use a soft-search broker such as Zuto or Oodle to explore eligibility without unnecessary hard applications.
- If your credit is weak, calculate the payment at the highest likely APR, not the advertised starting rate.
- Consider a cheaper car or larger deposit if the monthly payment only works at the limit of your budget.
Black Horse is the rate leader in this set, while Close Brothers and MotoNovo give dealer buyers broader HP and PCP routes. Oodle and Zuto focus on speed and comparison. Moneybarn is the access option for poor credit, but its rates demand the most caution. Choose based on the rate you are actually offered and the total repayment—not the number printed in the advert.
Car finance can become part of a wider debt problem if the monthly payment is stretched too far. Before rolling other borrowing into a new agreement, read Debt Consolidation Myths That Can Cost You More to avoid paying for a simpler-looking deal with a much higher total cost.